Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I do not understand how the US can charge someone with copyright infringement if that person is not a US citizen and has never been to the US. Is there an international agreement on how to handle infringement? Can Americans be extradited for infringing upon copyrights from other countries?


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hew_Raymond_Griffiths

This Australian never been to USA. After doing a similar piracy outfit, they got extradited to USA and prosecuted, jailed. Then when released they got jailed again for being an illegal alien, then deported and banned from USA. I wish I was kidding.

The extradition is legal for a few reasons:

+ Must be a crime in both countries

+ Must be a large jail sentence (Due to the excessive copyright penalties, this one is easy)

+ Must be authorised by the attorney general. The Australian government has the choice not to give up one of their citizens, but in this case they chose to do so.


Apparently US thinks their laws apply in the whole world. Team America world police is not a joke.


IANAL but I believe that,

Any country can charge anyone as long as its laws say it has standing to do so. Having your citizens harmed is a common reason.

Yes, there are international agreements regarding copyright infringement and regarding extraditions in general. In general (and again, IANAL) I think it's common for a country to accept to extradite someone if the alleged crime is also considered a crime locally.

I have no idea regarding the latter question :)


I assume if you are involved in stealing property from folks in the US (I assume many of the owners of the stolen material are American companies), the US has the right to extradite you. Seems reasonable to me.


Sure. Is that reciprocal? Would the US extradite a US citizen from the US to eg France to face prosecution for copyright infringement?


Haha, thanks for the good laugh!


The man in the article was an Estonian living in the Netherlands, so probably not a Dutch citizen.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: